Print Print

Making Sense of China’s 2017 Economic Growth Target

Chinese economy

Editor: Alexander Chipman Koty

During the annual Two Sessions meetings in early March, China’s political leaders announced their economic growth targets for 2017. The affair produced few surprises: the government predictably released an economic and political agenda that stressed the importance of stability and continuity.

Although the message was short on bold new policy announcements, the plan presented in Premier Li Keqiang’s annual Work Report – often likened to the U.S. State of the Union – offers clues to the direction and restructuring of the world’s second-largest economy, as well as the obstacles China faces going forward.

Given the deliberately crafted nature of the Work Report, slight changes in the way the government presents issues over previous years can signal shifts in policies and priorities. While China’s 2017 GDP target appears like a logical continuation of recent growth objectives at first glance, its careful wording delicately recalibrates expectations for the economy’s performance for the coming years.

 

Economic growth target

In the Work Report, Li pinned China’s 2017 GDP growth target at “around 6.5 percent, or higher if possible in practice.” This is a modest goal on the heels of 6.7 percent growth in 2016 – the lowest in 26 years.

While the 6.5 percent figure was widely anticipated, the added “or higher if possible in practice” provision was not. Notably, a more literal translation of Li’s Chinese-language speech stipulates that the government targets around 6.5 percent growth, but in practice tries “to achieve a better result.”

This remark may signal cautious optimism that China’s growth could rebound, or at least a subtle warning to officials not to be content with moderate growth. Taken this way, 6.5 percent sounds more like a baseline than a general approximation.

Alternatively, announcing that the government will merely strive towards higher growth rather than commit to it may be a signal for observers to temper their expectations.

 

Contextualizing 2017’s growth target

China’s leadership claims to be prioritizing long-term economic restructuring and minimizing financial risks over more superficial short-term growth indicators. The report repeatedly referred to the need to mitigate financial risks that could disrupt sustainable development, and more emphasis was given to ensuring employment rather than highlighting growth.

The ongoing reform and restructuring of the Chinese economy has been a persistent theme for several years. Still, posting impressive annual growth numbers remains an important concern for economic planners. While robust GDP growth rates add confidence to the Chinese economy, the slow pace of market-based reforms has frustrated many in the business community.

In 2015, the government put forward the “Two Doubles” project: to double the size of its 2010 GDP and per capita income in both urban and rural areas by 2020. Doing so requires an average of about 6.4-6.5 percent growth per year, and failure to meet this goal would be an embarrassing miscue for the government.

To help stimulate GDP growth, China has accumulated massive debt levels – particularly over the past two years. Li stated that the fiscal deficit for 2017 would remain at 3 percent of GDP, meaning an additional RMB 200 billion ($29 billion) worth of debt. Though the same 3 percent target was set for 2016, the fiscal deficit ended up reaching 3.8 percent by the year’s end. In 2015, the deficit was pegged at 2.3 percent.

China’s leadership understands the necessity of deepening reform efforts to ensure stable growth, but additional stimulus spending may be on the cards for it to meet its medium-term growth goals. This may especially be the case if they expect growth to continue to decline and fall short of the 6.4-6.5 percent average needed to attain the ‘Two Doubles.’

 

International trade and protectionism

Li’s Work Report vigorously re-emphasized China’s commitment to globalization and international trade, a reference to the protectionist rhetoric of President Donald Trump, and rising anti-trade sentiment in Europe. China’s commitment to globalization was repeatedly affirmed, including the declaration that “economic globalization is in the fundamental interests of all countries.”

The comments echo President Xi Jinping’s defense of globalization at the World Economic Forum in Davos in January. Beyond political rhetoric, however, they point to the genuine uncertainty facing China’s economy as a result of potential trade barriers and heightened tariffs. President Trump, for example, has threatened to slap taxes of up to 45 percent on imported goods from China.

Li further stated that “World economic growth remains sluggish, and both the de-globalization trend and protectionism are growing,” and added, “there are major uncertainties about the direction of the major economies’ policies and their spillover effects, and the factors that could cause instability and uncertainty are visibly increasing.”

The Work Report also referenced “profound changes in the international economic and political landscape” and “protectionism in its different forms”. While the risks certainly exist, ongoing emphasis on foreign protectionism may in the future be used to cover for disappointing domestic performance.

Despite China’s outward commitment to globalization, protectionism in China may also be on the rise. Germany’s ambassador to China recently said as much, while AmCham’s 2017 Business Climate Survey found that about 80 percent of surveyed companies feel that foreign companies are less welcome in China than in the past.

The consistency of China’s message on high-profile platforms – both at home and abroad – reveals a strategy to cultivate an image of a responsible protector of trade and internationalism. The message appears at odds with the experiences of foreign enterprises operating in the country, however, as they report experiencing the very trends of economic nationalism that the government publicly decries.

 

Key takeaways

Amid global uncertainty, domestic economic restructuring and high-profile leadership movement set to take place at the fall’s party congress, China’s economic targets in the 2017 Work Report emphasize cautious stability. The government has set moderate expectations for the economy’s performance and seems intent on minimizing structural risks.

Although the Work Report stresses a continuation of the status quo, it also raises acknowledgement of the difficulties that China faces in maintaining resilient growth in the coming years. By declaring that the government will just try to achieve higher growth rather than promising it, and warning of the domestic and international challenges that might impede growth, the Work Report may be subtly resetting expectations for China’s short- to medium-term economic performance.

Since its establishment in 1992, Dezan Shira & Associates has been guiding foreign clients through Asia’s complex regulatory environment and assisting them with all aspects of legal, accounting, tax, internal control, HR, payroll, and audit matters. As a full-service consultancy with operational offices across China, Hong Kong, India, and ASEAN, we are your reliable partner for business expansion in this region and beyond.

For inquiries, please email us at info@dezshira.com. Further information about our firm can be found at: www.dezshira.com.